Do I like iOS7?

Posted: September 27, 2013 in Random wifflings
Tags: , , , ,

We’re creatures of circumstance, you and I, our every thought a product of evolution-forged genes, cultural imprinting, and personal histories. I don’t trust what I think or what I feel. One has to distance oneself from one’s opinions and emotions and examine them from outside. “Why do I think that? Why do I feel this way?” These are questions I ask myself all the time. Especially when I’m walking the dog, or when there’s nothing on the telly. Or my wife has been mean to me.

I make irrational snap decisions, I am judgemental and dismissive. Everything I can conceive of comes freighted with unwelcome baggage. Only by confronting the irrational with rationality – and then recognise that rationality to be the product of that selfsame, fundamental irrationality – can one even hope to find the smallest chance at objectivity.

So I’ve given it a few days, and I have decided: I’m not very keen on iOS7‘s weirdly toytown design choices. I thought I didn’t like it when I first updated, but decided to give it some time (see above, you dig?). Now I’m pretty sure I actually don’t like it. No, screw pretty sure, I don’t.

Is it the fact that the new interface hurts my eyes? Is it that it’s weirdly floaty in a science-fictionally cool, but not very user-friendly kind of way? Is it that the screens and various elements sweep over each other like badly executed edit wipes in a Star Wars movie? Is it that, as someone put it on Twitter, it makes my iPhone look like the toy idea of a phone from Peppa Pig magazine? (I should have favourited this tweet, so I could give due credit. If it was you, let me know. It made me laugh. Ironically, it was that tweet that made me finally click “update”. I am dangerously contrary). I have thought on the probability that I’m just reacting with jerking knees to the shock of the new, and have tried to weigh my opinions accordingly.

I still don’t like it.

After a long love affair, Apple appears to have shot skeuomorphism directly in the temple. I can see why. Perhaps the old interface, with its cosy, snug-bar aesthetic, did look a little fusty and old-fashioned. Perhaps it really is time to abandon the stabilisers of the familiar and ride off assuredly on the bicycles of new technology, our jacked-in heads held high. But it did work on the iPhone (and still does on my iPad), and the new one doesn’t work as well. I have not a clue about the new features. Like everyone else, I barely skim-read the proud proclamation accompanying the update. I just clicked “update” and “I have read your 33 pages of user agreement” (Of course I didn’t! Does anyone? When Apple come to collect my first-born, no doubt I’ll wish I had). Now I’m aged 40, and probably not fit to programme an antique VCR, I doubt I’ll find the new doodads easily. Perhaps I’ll ask a reader of Peppa Pig magazine to help me.

So I’m judging this update entirely on the look and immediate usability of it. I am sure 80% of this opinion is still “Urgh, it’s new. Don’t like it. Don’t LIKE IT!” rather than anything grown up. But 20% of it is “Ow! My fucking eyes!”, and that’s not good for something dependent on interaction with eyes.

The interface has all the hallmarks of something that has been prompted by a sudden desire to be different. It is a design led, rather than utility led, effort. I’ve been involved in a few of them myself, some even worked. But just because that green baize gaming table was a step too far (and it really was, I mean, really), it doesn’t mean you should burn the whole damn thing down to the ground.

No doubt in three months I’ll sheepishly re-read this and ajudge my past self very wrong, but until then, future me, I remain grumpily unconvinced.

  1. Anne Lyle says:

    This is why I haven’t updated yet (that, and my hardware is at the lower end of compatibility, which means it’ll run like a 3-legged dog). I feel like they’ve thrown the design baby out with the skeuomorphic bathwater, tbh. Can Apple really think of nothing better than to ape the candy colours of Windows Surface? Sheesh.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s